| 1 | — |  | Sherlock Holmes Short Stories | NOISER | |
| 2 | — |  | Scary Horror Stories by Dr. NoSleep | Dr. NoSleep Studios | |
| 3 | — |  | The Sleepy Bookshelf | Slumber Studios | |
| 4 | 3 |  | The NoSleep Podcast | Creative Reason Media Inc. | |
| 5 | 6 |  | The Royals of Malibu | Emerald Audio | |
| 6 | 2 |  | Imagination Amplified | GZM Shows | |
| 7 | 1 |  | Midnight Burger | Business Goose Media | |
| 8 | 55 | A | Anne of Green Gables | Lucy Maud Montgomery | |
| 9 | 21 |  | The Saints | The Merry Beggars | |
| 11 | 18 |  | The Archers | BBC Radio 4 | |
| 12 | — |  | Stories from the Village of Nothing Much | Wellness Loud | |
| 13 | 8 |  | Send Me To Sleep: Books and stories for bedtime | Send Me To Sleep | |
| 14 | — |  | Discovering Dad | GZM Shows | |
| 15 | — |  | Mina and Lucy's Guide to Slaying Dracula | GZM Shows | |
| 17 | 18 |  | Dirty Diana | QCODE | |
| 18 | 21 |  | DERELICT | Night Rocket Productions | |
| 19 | 10 |  | Sherlock & Co. | Goalhanger | |
| 20 | 54 |  | Old Gods of Appalachia | DeepNerd Media | |
| 21 | 22 |  | How i Died | Audiohm Media | |
| 23 | — |  | Station 151 | Pale Matter | Realm | |
| 24 | 66 |  | The Gentleman From Hell | Maeltopia | |
| 25 | 85 | C | COLD TAPES | Free Turn | |
| 27 | 54 | L | Leylines | Good Story Guild | |
| 29 | 95 |  | Narcissa | QCODE | |
| 30 | 101 |  | Phoebe Reads a Mystery | Vox Media Podcast Network | |
| 31 | — |  | Moan Audios – Spicy ASMR | Dipsea | |
| 32 | 8 |  | Mysteries at Midnight - Mystery Stories read in the soothing style of a bedtime story | Sleep Cove | |
| 33 | — |  | Mythology & Fiction Explained | Marios Christou | |
| 34 | 135 |  | Primal | Voyage Media | |
| 35 | 95 |  | Anne of Green Gables | Mary Kate Wiles | |
| 37 | — |  | Rabbits | Public Radio Alliance | |
| 40 | 7 |  | 1001 Classic Short Stories & Tales | Jon Hagadorn | |
| 42 | 22 | U | Un(con)Trolled | Kimberly Renee | |
| 43 | 21 |  | Just Roll With It | JRWI | |
| 44 | 28 |  | The Unexplainable Disappearance of Mars Patel | GZM Shows | |
| 45 | 53 |  | Mayfair Watchers Society | Bloody FM | |
| 46 | 36 |  | Night Falls: Bedtime Story, Sleep Story, Sleep Podcast | Sleepiest: Bedtime Story, Sleep Story, Sleep Podcast | |
| 47 | 33 |  | Chilling Tales for Dark Nights: A Horror Anthology and Scary Stories Series Podcast | Chilling Entertainment, LLC & Studio71 | |
| 48 | 13 |  | Ronstadt | QCODE, Wood Elf, Mythical | |
| 49 | 67 |  | Horror Hill: A Horror Anthology and Scary Stories Series Podcast | Chilling Entertainment, LLC & Studio71 | |
| 50 | 36 |  | Marvel's Wastelanders: Doom | Marvel & SiriusXM | |
| 51 | 8 |  | The Strata | Mark R. Healy | |
| 52 | 34 |  | Elucidity | Koji Steven Sakai | |
| 53 | 32 |  | Woodbine: A Parkdale Haunts Production | Alex Nursall & Emily Kellogg | |
| 54 | 41 |  | Lighthouse Horror Podcast | Lighthouse Horror | |
| 55 | — | S | Sports Horn | Stak | |
| 56 | 24 |  | 1001 Sherlock Holmes Stories & The Best of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle | Arthur Conan Doyle | |
| 57 | 31 |  | Sapphic Stories - Spicy WLW Fiction | Dipsea | |
| 58 | 9 | T | The Occult Adventures of Norman P. Blank | Laughing Skull Audio | |
| 61 | 36 |  | Fictional Men Written By Women | Dipsea | |
| 62 | 26 | I | Inkommers | Maroela Media | |
| 63 | 26 | T | Twilight Tales Podcast | Meg Celine | |
| 64 | 17 |  | Six Minutes | GZM Shows | |
| 65 | 23 |  | SCP Archives | Bloody FM | |
| 66 | 47 | N | NOCTURNAL | Scott Sigler | |
| 68 | 34 |  | I Am Echo | Voyage Media | |
| 69 | 24 |  | Acephale: Horror Fiction | Jeffrey Walker | |
| 70 | 82 | A | ANCESTOR | Scott Sigler | |
| 71 | 42 |  | Scary Stories Told in the Dark: A Horror Anthology Series | Chilling Entertainment, LLC & Studio71 | |
| 73 | 21 |  | Blackout | QCODE & Endeavor Content | |
| 74 | 19 |  | Escaping Denver | Escaping Denver / Curiouscast | |
| 75 | 34 |  | MSA | My Story Animated | |
| 76 | 11 |  | CreepsMcPasta Creepypasta Radio | Creeps McPasta | |
| 77 | 10 | T | The Pact Audiobook Project | Speedchuck | |
| 78 | 17 |  | The Adventure Zone | The McElroys | |
| 79 | 31 | A | Academy | Audible | AT WILL MEDIA | |
| 81 | 43 |  | Murder in HR | Caspian Studios | |
| 82 | 3 |  | Romantasy - Spicy Fantasy Stories | Dipsea | |
| 84 | 28 | C | Curious Matter Anthology | Knightsville Workshop | |
| 85 | 34 |  | People Who Knew Me | BBC Radio 5 Live | |
| 86 | 3 |  | Strange Matter: The Witch Who Came in From the Cold | Realm | |
| 87 | 72 |  | Harry Potter and The Methods of Rationality Audiobook | Jack Voraces | |
| 88 | 26 |  | Someone Just Like You: Horror Stories | Jeremy Ellett | |
| 89 | 13 | H | Holmes Alone: Sherlock Holmes Stories | Jake Urry | |
| 90 | 57 |  | Oz 9 | Gated Galaxies | |
| 91 | 20 |  | The White Vault | Fool and Scholar Productions | |
| 92 | 24 |  | Horror Stories | After Dark Studios | |
| 93 | 73 | K | Katbosbult | Maroela Media | |
| 94 | 37 |  | Borrasca | QCODE | |
| 95 | 6 |  | Erotic Stories from Wylde in Bed | Devlin Wylde | |
| 96 | — |  | Nightingale | GZM Shows | |
| 97 | 31 |  | The Lovecraft Investigations | BBC Radio 4 | |
| 98 | — | M | Moriarty: The Devil's Game | Charles Kindinger | |
| 99 | 50 | T | The Genome Killer | Voyage Media | |
| 100 | 22 | T | The Drop Pod: A Warhammer 40K Podcast | Blake and Garrett | |
| 101 | 88 |  | The Valentyne Heresy: A Warhammer 40K RPG | Dumb-Dumbs & Dice | |
| 102 | 13 |  | Paralyzed | Bloody FM | |
| 103 | 63 |  | Welcome to Night Vale | Night Vale Presents | |
| 104 | 25 |  | Passenger List | Passenger List and Radiotopia | |
| 105 | 3 |  | Drew Blood's Dark Tales - A Horror Anthology and Scary Stories Podcast | Chilling Entertainment, LLC & Studio71 | |
| 108 | 12 |  | Be. Scared | Be. Busta and Studio71 | |
| 109 | — |  | The Bearded Wit | Matthew Ogden | |
| 110 | 32 |  | Creepy | Bloody FM | |
| 112 | 13 |  | The Antiquarium of Sinister Happenings | Bloody FM | |
| 115 | 19 |  | Undertow: Familiar Haunts | Realm | |
| 116 | 28 |  | Scare You To Sleep | Bloody FM | |
| 117 | 45 |  | Unwell, a Midwestern Gothic Mystery | Audacious Machine Creative | |
| 118 | 72 |  | The Heresies Of Radulf Burntwine | Zachary Golden | |
| 119 | 6 |  | 1001 Stories For The Road | Host Jon Hagadorn | |
| 120 | 17 |  | Mythology | Spotify Studios | |
